• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Ruhlman
  • About Michael
  • My Books
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • From Scratch

yolk, lemon juice, salt, oil

Published: May 21, 2008 · Modified: May 21, 2008 by Michael Ruhlman · 87 Comments

Anz_0062_3                                                                                                 all photographs © Donna Turner Ruhlman

Finishing up the revisions of a manuscript and going over some fat-based sauces has returned me to the mayonnaise.  Like the popover, it’s the story of a great transformation. Yolk, lemon juice, salt and oil.
Anz_0067_3

There simply isn’t anything like it when you make it yourself—you can’t buy this stuff. But I’ll bet you have everything you need to make it right now.  I’ll include a recipe at the end of this post.
Anz_0094_3

Two things are critical to remember for those who have never made a mayonnaise.  You need enough liquid (water or lemon juice) to maintain the emulsion, so don’t skimp on this.  Second, begin adding the oil very slowly, just a couple drops of oil off the end of a spoon into the yolk while whisking, then another few drops.  This establishes the emulsion.  Then you can add the oil in a more steady stream.

Anz_0111

Donna took these pictures several weeks ago using natural light in our kitchen and frankly, they’re why I wanted to post about mayonnaise.  But I hope they inspire you to make your own.
Anz_0133_3

You will have taken a tasteless fluid oil and transformed it into an ethereal sauce through craftsmanship and care.  Add a tablespoon of minced shallot, and maybe a little extra lemon juice for an extraordinary dipping sauce for an artichoke, or blanched and shocked cauliflower, or to put on some boiled new potatoes.  It’s magical stuff.  Or just put it on a BLT--it'll be the best sandwich you've had in a long time.

Here’s the recipe adapted from Charcuterie.

1 large organic egg yolk
½ teaspoon/5 grams salt
1 teaspoon/5 milliliters water
1 teaspoon/5 milliliters lemon juice (or 2 for a lemony mayo)
1 cup/250 milliliters vegetable oil

Combine yolks salt, water and lemon juice in a 2.5 quart bowl.  Fold a hand towel into a ring on the counter and set the bowl in this ring to hold it steady while you whisk.  Using a sauce or balloon whip (whisk), stir the ingredients together.

Add the oil slowly while whisking vigorously.  It helps to measure out your oil into a cup that pours well in a wire-this stream; alternately you can start your emulsion by drizzling the oil off a spoon, then pouring the oil after the emulsion has begun.  Add a few drops of oil as you begin to wisk; when the emulsion becomes creamy, you may increase the speed with which you add the oil to a thin stream. From the beginning the mixture should be thick enough to hold its shape and look luxuriously creamy. Add the oil too quickly and it will break, that is, it will turn soupy.  When all the oil is incorporated add remaining lemon juice to taste.  If the mayonnaise is too thick, it can be thinned by whisking in a little water.

If it breaks, put a teaspoon of water in a clean bowl and start the process over by dribbling in the broken mayonnaise while whisking.

URGENT UPDATE AND MSG TO BECKS & POSH AND RIPERT: From Shannon at momwantsacure: "Ha!! I just proved Eric Ripert and Becks & Posh WRONG!!!!! Tell them that menstruating women can make a fabulously perfect mayonnaise!"

Previous Post: « Food Notes May 19
Next Post: What Does Molecular Gastronomy Mean? »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Adele

    May 21, 2008 at 12:34 pm

    Once again, fabulous pictures by Donna; I'm having company for dinner tonight, and I thought I had the menu set, but now I want to make something that requires mayo or aioli -- maybe I'll steam some artichokes.

    Reply
  2. HappyHoarfrost

    May 21, 2008 at 1:05 pm

    It broke, and so did my pride.
    I don't know if it was that I chose the somewhat strident lemony path, or that my 4-year-old helper does not know the meaning of the words "A drop at a time." ("Look, Mommy--FROSTING!")
    But THANK YOU for including the escape hatch in "If it breaks"--we got it reassembled and it made a smashing tarragon-chicken salad.

    Reply
  3. Erinn

    May 21, 2008 at 1:05 pm

    Oh mayonaise, why do I fear you? I do though, but am feeling bolstered up by how "ethereal" you make it sound. Perhaps it's time to face the fear. Thanks for a great post.

    Reply
  4. Barbara

    May 21, 2008 at 1:57 pm

    Mayonnaise isn't difficult--just like hollandaise isn't difficult. You just need to be patient, and careful, that is all.

    Be bold and fearless in the kitchen--when you are working with simple, easily acquired, not very expensive ingredients like egg yolks and oil, lemon juice and salt, if you mess it up, so what? Try again. If you don't get mayonnaise straight out of the gate, you will get it on your second try.

    And Michael is right--real mayonnaise is the best tasting stuff imaginable.

    Reply
  5. Darcie

    May 21, 2008 at 1:59 pm

    Those photographs are gorgeous. I have been making mayo by hand since I saw Jacques Pepin do it on his PBS video, which I received for Christmas. I use a little mustard in mine to assist the emulsion.

    There is something so satisfying about the process - the transformation is almost magical.

    Reply
  6. ruhlman

    May 21, 2008 at 2:08 pm

    happyhoarfrost, good for you for disciplining your sauce. i know for a fact it is all but impossible to cook thoughtfully when there's a four year old in the room. and you need to pay attention when you're making a mayonnaise; this is part of the pleasure.

    also, and i should have put this in the post, it is common knowledge in France, according both to Eric Ripert and Becks & Posh, that women who are menstruating cannot make mayonnnaise. It always breaks. Always.

    Reply
  7. Joan

    May 21, 2008 at 2:17 pm

    What about zee moutarde ? Ah, my chef has made me make mayonnaise many times. Due to an injury from my previous office job, my arms are still not used to it!

    Reply
  8. iron stef

    May 21, 2008 at 2:35 pm

    I've been meaning to do this...and these photos may have pushed me over the edge. I have a terrible aversion to mayo, you see, and I know it's crazy...but it's just...blech...I can't eat it. I want to test my theory that I'm not actually a mayo hater, but perhaps I'm a mayo snob and must have fresh home made mayo.

    Reply
  9. Darcie

    May 21, 2008 at 2:41 pm

    "also, and i should have put this in the post, it is common knowledge in France, according both to Eric Ripert and Becks & Posh, that women who are menstruating cannot make mayonnaise. It always breaks. Always."

    I'll have to test this hypothesis in a few weeks LOL.

    Reply
  10. Messy

    May 21, 2008 at 2:51 pm

    All right, if anyone wants to mock the amateur over the following question, just go ahead. Sigh. I'm used to it....

    Is there any rule that says I have to do this with a whisk? I freely admit to not being a whisk goddess. Can I use my handy dandy little KitchenAid hand mixer instead?

    I speak as the person for whom the walking and chewing of gum is a challenge. I'm still recovering from cutting the same finger in an "onion incident" that I cut a mere three weeks ago (Another "onion incident". The only comment The Boy had for that one was "Don't bleed on dinner.") It's going to be a beautiful scar...

    Reply
  11. claudia

    May 21, 2008 at 3:02 pm

    mayonaisse really is a little molecular miracle. i made my first batch about a month ago. broke it. googled it. then fixed it. i added lemon zest and very finely minced garlic, used a fancy olive oil too. i gotta say it was delicious in everything it graced.

    Reply
  12. Natalie Sztern

    May 21, 2008 at 3:26 pm

    Maybe that's why my popovers failed!!LOL

    Reply
  13. Bob delGrosso

    May 21, 2008 at 3:55 pm

    Messy
    The Kitchen Aide hand mixer works fine, so too does a food processor. Neat Cuisinart food processor trick that eliminates the need to dribble in the oil manually:

    Put the egg and lemon juice/ vinegar in the bowl with the blade. Put the "pusher" in the neck and note the pinhole in the bottom of the pusher. Turn on the machine, mix the egg and liquid and dump the oil in the pusher. It'll dribble in at precisely the right rate. If after a while you become impatient, you can pour the oil in manually.

    Reply
  14. drago

    May 21, 2008 at 3:57 pm

    Messy - There are "blender mayo" recipes out there but I believe the ingredients are slightly different. Alton Brown's recipe calls for using the whole egg - I believe the proteins in the white hold everything together. http://www.foodnetwork.com/food/recipes/recipe/0,1977,FOOD_9936_16261,00.html

    It's not quite as good as the method that Michael uses above, but it's also generally better than the stuff from the jar. (Read the ingredients, I dare you.)

    As an aside, I'm still amazed at how many people think that mayo is a dairy product...

    Reply
  15. chadzilla

    May 21, 2008 at 4:05 pm

    I hope the contestants on Top Chef Chicago last week read your blog. They were all dismayed for the 'relay race' challenge because they didn't know if they could make mayonnaise without a food processor. That floored me... why in the hell would you enter a show called 'Top Chef' if you cannot make mayo... (and I should not have said all the contestants... just the lame ones).
    Times are really changing in this industry.

    Reply
  16. Connor

    May 21, 2008 at 5:01 pm

    Call me lazy, but I use my mini food processor to make mayo even though I can make it by hand. Works great every time, and because it's so easy, I make the homemade version often. I typically use half grapeseed, half extra virgin olive oil.

    One of my favorite ways to use homemade mayo is turning it into a remoulade sauce by adding chopped cornichons, capers, whole-grain mustard, and some cayenne. Great with seafood, even better with fried pickles!

    Reply
  17. Anthony Silverbrow

    May 21, 2008 at 5:17 pm

    Why no mustard? Never made it without, but I'd imagine you need it for that little kick.

    Reply
  18. Claudia (the Original)

    May 21, 2008 at 5:57 pm

    I've made mayo both by whisk and by food processor - they work equally well. And once you start the mayo/aioli ball rolling, the different flavor possibilities are endless. My current favorite? A Meyer lemon aioli that just rocks every bite of fish I've ever put it on.

    Reply
  19. Tags

    May 21, 2008 at 6:34 pm

    I think it's - straight men can't make mayonnaise.

    I've seen no evidence that either Bud Abbott or Dean Martin have ever made mayonnaise.

    But that's just my own experience.

    Reply
  20. the milliner

    May 21, 2008 at 8:45 pm

    Oh man, I'm dying to eat homemade mayo again. Have been on a 9 month hiatus due to the growing boy in my belly.

    Definitely nice photos.

    Reply
  21. Kate

    May 21, 2008 at 11:35 pm

    Oh, my gosh, that's beautiful. I want some NOW, with some of that nice plump asparagus from the guy at the Oxbow market.

    Reply
  22. Chris

    May 21, 2008 at 11:44 pm

    I've always wanted to make my own mayo, but never got around to it. After reading your post, I checked the crisper and found a solitary lemon. Since I had everything else, I gave it a go. It came out perfect (no breaking)! Thanks Michael! Tomorrow will be BLT night.

    On a side note, I thought of an odd thing after I finished the mayo...I recently got into making my own bread. I know several other people like me that were too intimidated to try making their own bread. Why is that people (including me) won't mess with bread making, but people think nothing of trying a new dish for dinner containing fish, chicken, beef, numerous spices, etc. which could turn out downright inedible and wind up in the trash.

    It costs me .89 cents to make a loaf of bread. Even if it turns out to be an inedible blob, I'm still out less than $1. If that dinner turns out to be garbage, I'm looking at tossing $20-25 (or more) in the trash or feeding it to the dogs (assuming they'll even eat it).

    Why are people willing to take an expensive chance on exotic and/or expensive food, but not an ungodly cheap one on a food that, when done well, seems to me to be a real sign of culinary skill?

    Reply
  23. michelle @ TNS

    May 22, 2008 at 12:00 am

    mayo has never looked so pornorifically delicious. if it wasn't midnight right now, i'd be making some.

    hell, maybe i'll do it anyway.

    Reply
  24. carri

    May 22, 2008 at 2:43 am

    some people are so afraid of mayonnaise...not just the making of it, but the very existence of it on their sandwich! Oh, sad misinformed souls they are!

    Reply
  25. luis

    May 22, 2008 at 8:01 am

    Claudia, (A Meyer lemon aioli that just rocks every bite of fish I've ever put it on).

    Thanks for the tip Claudia. I have been looking around for just such a thing to use during my fishing vacation. I am considering working on a gribiche and a mango sauce as well. I'd like to have half a dozen options in my pocket or some mother sauce that can be twisted six different ways by this time next month. Feel free to share your recipe with us.

    I have to admit Michael, that after this post I will be trying your recipe. Be fun to give it a go. Michael everything you post is basically simple and really elevates and expands our abilities in the kitchen. Bravo!

    Reply
  26. jbrew

    May 22, 2008 at 9:06 am

    Why is there not a concern for salmonella?

    Reply
  27. Doodad

    May 22, 2008 at 9:06 am

    Perfect timing.

    I have to make hollandaise as homework for my internship in a local kitchen. I figured I would make mayo at the same time since all the same ingredients are out.

    Don't break on me baby.

    Reply
  28. oneeyedcarmen

    May 22, 2008 at 9:14 am

    jbrew,

    the odds of contracting salmonella from eggs is incredibly small. the inside of an egg is a sterile environment, so there is no bacteria to worry about in there. the shell is another story, but even then, the mother-hen would have needed to be a carrier, the egg not been pasturized, and for you to have been mighty clumsy and gotten egg shells in with the yummy goodness. (this is not even accounting for the inablilty for the bacteria to survive in the acidity of the lemon juice)

    Reply
  29. Shannon

    May 22, 2008 at 9:22 am

    Ha!! I just proved Eric Ripert and Becks & Posh WRONG!!!!! Tell them that menstruating women can make a fabulously perfect mayonnaise!

    How long does the mayo keep in the refrigerator for?

    It tastes great, btw. Thanks for posting this.

    Reply
  30. oneeyedcarmen

    May 22, 2008 at 9:25 am

    T M I

    Reply
  31. ruhlman

    May 22, 2008 at 9:27 am

    a few things. yes, food processor will usually work but the texture i find to be slightly different. just as a mayonaise made in a heavy mortar and pestle is different form a whisk. there's something about the whisk texture i love.

    mustard is excellent in mayo, and also helps to strengthen the emulsion.

    this will keep for a week in the fridge if you don't add shallots or herbs. it's mainly a flavor issue.

    salmonella: in fact because chicken overies can be infected with salmonella, the yolk can be contaminated as well. i've been eating raw yolk my whole life and have never to my knowledge gotten ill from it. but: it's best to use organic eggs or eggs from your farmers market. it's worth the extra expense.

    Reply
  32. Chris

    May 22, 2008 at 9:36 am

    Regarding the salmonella, I recall an episode of Good Eats in which Alton made mayo. After it was finished he put it in a jar and left it on the counter for a couple of hours.

    His reason for this was two-fold: 1) Refrigeration will not kill the bacteria; it just prevents it from growing. 2) Lemon juice will kill the bacteria, and it does a better job killing the bacteria at room temperature than at refrigerated temps.

    Reply
  33. Claudia (the Original)

    May 22, 2008 at 9:54 am

    Luis, feel free to e-mail me at bukigreco@aol.com and I'll get the recipe out to you.

    Michael, I'm very surprised you'd even repeat such a canard as the mayo-menstruation one, as propagated by the French. Ripert, too, should know better to repeat that, though I don't think he believes it himself (nor, I think, do you)! Shannon, thanks for taking a hit for the girls' team and putting that old wives' tale to rest. Mon Dieu!

    Reply
  34. Shannon

    May 22, 2008 at 11:11 am

    Wow.

    So, did anyone see Bourdain on Conan O'Brien last night?

    Reply
  35. Joan

    May 22, 2008 at 11:47 am

    Chadzilla - word !

    Reply
  36. ErikaK

    May 22, 2008 at 12:15 pm

    Mmmmm... homemade mayo is the best.
    I do find that I have breaks more often with the food processor than by hand. I might try the Kitchenaid with the wire whip next time though. I actually think my problem is not enough liquid, I don't add much lemon juice so next time I'll use that tsp of h2o. I usually do aioli too with lots of garlic & a dab of dijon mustard, goes perfect with roast lamb - I even converted the Aussie grandmother from the yucky mint jelly!

    Reply
  37. Yvo

    May 22, 2008 at 12:50 pm

    Hmm.. how much mayo does this make - like I have a week to use it, how many sandwiches could I use it on? (I do like mayo but I don't know if I can happily/healthily eat a whole jar in a week, for example.)

    Awesome, I will definitely attempt to make this sometime soon.

    Reply
  38. ruhlman

    May 22, 2008 at 12:58 pm

    makes about a cup. you want to make less, reduce the amount of oil and water and lemon by half.

    Reply
  39. milo

    May 22, 2008 at 2:11 pm

    So to make less is it best to just use less oil, water, lemon and still use one yolk instead of trying to divide it in half?

    Reply
  40. ihop

    May 22, 2008 at 2:58 pm

    Man, my mayo kept breaking. Maybe I should buy a whisk and a proper mixing bowl, instead of trying to make it work with a fork and a large piece of Tupperware. Anyone made successful fork-whisked mayo, or should I splurge?

    (I've been moving around a lot lately and it's forced me to reduce my kitchen implements to the bare minimum. No good!)

    ~ihop
    http://totallykickassparties.blogspot.com

    Reply
  41. ruhlman

    May 22, 2008 at 3:05 pm

    Actually, you can make mayo with a fork and a plate. I've never done it, but it's intriguingly described in an early chapter of John Thorne's Mouth Wide Open.

    Reply
  42. john

    May 22, 2008 at 5:15 pm

    those are great photos, the lighting is perfect for brining out the feeling of cooking in a home kitchen.
    "food porn" is a fantastic art in my book, and i also love taking photos of foodstuffs, from individual ingredients to complete meals. what a fantastic medium, and you get to eat it when you are done!

    Reply
  43. Tags

    May 22, 2008 at 5:19 pm

    As Jimmy Durante used to say, "Everybody wants to get into the act!"

    http://www.philly.com/inquirer/food/20080522_MAYOmania.html

    Reply
  44. marlene

    May 22, 2008 at 7:40 pm

    In the past, I've found the KA bowl too deep to do a good job of whisking mayonnaise and I hate making it by hand, although I can. They recently came out with a shallow bowl and wire whip to fit the KA's and it does a great job of making mayonnaise.

    Reply
  45. luis

    May 22, 2008 at 10:36 pm

    ""Wow.

    So, did anyone see Bourdain on Conan O'Brien last night?

    Posted by: Shannon | May 22, 2008 at 11:11 AM""

    Shannon Bourdain was on TOP CHEF last night. Our dog was devouring his bone and my fingers..as it all went down....ouch!!ouch!!
    See once the dog gets through all the meat in the bone he comes to us for help.... That's when all the crunching and cracking starts... but I digress...
    Bourdain the bully beat up on the Top Chef sweathogs pretty good. I can't say he was wrong or that he didn't point out the issues to the audience. No! He did point these things out. However it felt to me like he was out of context. These top chef people are just journeyman and women kitchen sweathogs. To elevate them to top anything so Buchollic and others Bourdain can crush them for our entertainment is as far as I am concerned similar to the old Roman Christians to the Lions theme. Hell, I been there, my hands have been slapped by the nuns with huge heavy rulers and Bourdain and the rest of the judges can shove the t-shirt up their bony arses. Top Chef is like a situation where someone goes hunting for quail with a freaking tomahauk missile barrage. That is just not the way folks....not at all.
    This is why I personally admire Micahel Ruhlman. Michael elevates folks and introduces them to techniques that bring happiness to their lives. He has unusually rare qualities. I think.

    Reply
  46. Charlotte

    May 23, 2008 at 12:35 am

    Okay, I'll fess up -- I regularly make the immersion blender version of mayonnaise. One whole egg (I add an extra yolk as well), juice of half a lemon, a splodge of mustard in a wide-mouth pint mason jar. Stick the immersion blender in, then pour a cup of oil in on top of it all (I like half olive oil, half walnut oil). Hit the go button on the immersion blender, lift it up and down a couple of times until everything is blended, and lo -- a pint of lovely, probably-not-totally-authentic-but-still-better-than-Hellman's mayo. Sometimes I add a clove of garlic and a big pinch of allepo pepper because I'm like that. Easy. Cheap (even with organic eggs). And very very yummy.

    Reply
  47. luis

    May 23, 2008 at 10:26 am

    Charlotte, excellent suggestion for the home cook. Real easy and as you suggest the flavor itself probably comes more from the ingredients you use than from the actual emulsion itself. ( I am 100% certain that Rhulman can tell the difference between the two ) Only way to be certain is to do it both ways. At least once.
    This on the surface appears to be a slide rule vs calculator issue. ( seen any slide rules latelly?? ) A compound mayo reminds me of the compound butter suggestion Rhulman posted about earlier. The sky is the limit in this sauce. I wonder if you/we could replace balsamic vinegar, lime, tamarind juice, or bitter orange instead of the lemon???? hmmmmm......sky is the limit with this technique. Bravo!

    Reply
  48. Kevin

    May 23, 2008 at 11:54 am

    Donna,
    Gorgeous photos!

    Reply
  49. Claudia (the Original)

    May 23, 2008 at 1:04 pm

    Luis, Bourdain was on Top Chef on Wedneday night, and on Conan on Tuesday. (He did not, however, make mayo on either show!)

    Reply
  50. Lisa

    May 23, 2008 at 2:07 pm

    ihop, the tupperware is a magnet for oils and other contaminants. Even if you think you've cleaned it, there are still molecules of assorted things clinging, waiting to interact with your food. You probably won't be able to whip egg whites in that bowl either.

    The other problem might be water. If your instruments were at all damp, that can interfere with the process. Older cookbooks warn of not making mayo while it's raining or overly damp outside. I use my blender to make it, and have only had it break when I didn't start with a blender I allowed to dry for at least an hour while completely taken apart.

    I started making mayo in 1985. I love changing the ingredients around and adding fresh herbs. While citrus fruit is really good (try using limes, and adding chopped fresh dill at the end and letting it sit overnight) don't forget that vinegars can be used as well as long as the acid content is there. 100 year old balsamic won't work, but red raspberry vinegar with a little fresh thyme is very nice.

    Reply
  51. ruhlman

    May 23, 2008 at 3:32 pm

    claudia the original, bourdain hasn't made a mayonnaise since the seventies in escoffier room. and i doubt his arthritic joints could pull it off now, not at this time of the month, anyway.

    Reply
  52. Kate in the NW

    May 23, 2008 at 4:04 pm

    Oooh I just love it when you guys get zingy. Very entertaining. Like mayo with cayenne - don't forget good ol' cayenne. Make your BLT Cajun! I'm also going to try using some Alder-smoked salt in the cayenne mayo. Thanks for the inspiration.

    I think that mentsruation myth was created as a test - any fool guy who believed or propagated it had to make the mayo - his wrists were probably built up plenty strong enough to "wisk" all day (because with attitudes like that he'd not be getting very far with any women worth their salt, alder-smoked or not).

    ;-P

    Reply
  53. amber

    May 23, 2008 at 5:32 pm

    totally inspired! we're having pub grub for dinner so i can use up the last of the maui onions i bought last week and i'm going to attempt homemade mayo to put on the burgers. who knew pictures of something as simple as mayo could be so drool-worthy?!

    Reply
  54. Wilmita

    May 23, 2008 at 6:39 pm

    I am not an egg person; still I have made mayonnaise many times and thing homemade is better than jarred.

    Still, picking on Anthony Bourdain's arthritic joints is a low shot.

    I am only a year older than Bourdain, but my"clutch knee" from my standard transmission when I drive is beginning to pain me.

    I cannot imagine 28 years of crouching down to retrieve things from 'lowboys', etc. could do.

    However, I would NOT up driving a stick shift until I cannot anymore.

    -Wilmita

    Reply
  55. Jordi ST

    May 23, 2008 at 8:22 pm

    I've been doing all i oli -garlic & oil, with a little help from a yolk 🙂 for two years now but never used water/lemon, so maybe that's why the emulsion sometimes becomes too thick.

    I have a question: What about the egg temperature when starting the mayonnaise? I was told it should be at room temperature, and never have tried with a refrigerated egg to see what happens

    -Jordi

    Reply
  56. luis

    May 23, 2008 at 10:09 pm

    Arthritic Joints....ooohhhhhh toooo much information. Guess I can not bash the poor fella anymore. Gee thanks....Michael!
    time for confession AGAIN!!!!!!!....still working through my pennance from the last time. Practically live in tha place.
    Guess I will light a candle for Anthony...He seems too young for knee replacements...maybe he has a plan? like destroying each and every major organ in his body at the same time? before passing?
    Right out of my old coach's playbook. No wonder he runs around tatooing skeletons on his arse....

    Reply
  57. jsmeeker

    May 23, 2008 at 10:33 pm

    I whipped up some mayo today. I've made it before, but always with the Cuisinart. But today, because of this thread I broke out the whisk and the bowl and did it by hand.

    I sort of halved the recipe. Only used 1/2 cup of oil. My water component might have been a bit MORE than half of what was called for above, but it still worked out perfectly. So creamy. So rich. Not at all like Hellmans. Of course, neither is the stuff that comes out of the Cuisinart.

    So, now the question is pose is this. How much oil can one emulsify with a SINGLE egg yolk. Can you do TWO cups of oil? More?

    Reply
  58. Steven Morehead

    May 23, 2008 at 11:28 pm

    One egg yolk will emulsify 3 to 4 ounces of oil if I remember right. I have always heard that you should never use extra-virgin olive oil in a mechanical device as it destroys all the flavor. There was some molecular reasoning behind it. Really there is not that much work that goes into making an emulsification, unless you are making a HUGE batch. The egg does most of the work for you, if you have to force it to work you have probably done something wrong in the beginning.

    Reply
  59. ruhlman

    May 24, 2008 at 8:33 am

    Actually, you can emulsify a dozen cups or more with one yolk.

    Reply
  60. Bob delGrosso

    May 24, 2008 at 10:11 am

    Steve Morehead, JS Meeker et al

    The role of the egg in the formation of the mayonnaise emulsion is highly overstated.

    It's not the egg that is responsible for creating the emulsion. Rather, it is the enhanced attraction between the slightly polar (charged) regions of the oil and more polar water molecules that occurs when the oil is mechanically dispersed (whisked/sprayed) in the form of tiny droplets. Also, most oil are not entirely pure and contain "impurities" that aid in forming an emulsion. The same is true of most of the watery liquids that are used to make typical culinary emulsions (e.g. vinegar, lemon juice).

    It's entirely possible to make an emulsion of oil and say, lemon juice, without adding any egg. You'll need to use a machine to do it and it won't taste like mayonnaise, but it will be an emulsion.

    In the end I think it's better to think of the egg as something that is added to "assist" in the creation of the emulsion but it is by no means essential.

    BTW, mustard also contains particles and lecithin that act as emulsifying agents that help out too. Also, possible to create a sauce that is very similar in texture to mayonnaise using finely milled mustard and oil. I think this is a classic (not Creole) "Sauce Remoulade."

    (Is that right Ruhlman?)

    Reply
  61. Gabrielle

    May 24, 2008 at 12:14 pm

    Donna's photographs are always beautiful, but here she has outdone herself. Natural light + homemade mayonnaise = food orgasm.

    Mayo has never looked yummier - thanks! 🙂

    Reply
  62. Emile Petrone

    May 24, 2008 at 12:25 pm

    Making it right now!

    Reply
  63. Shannon

    May 24, 2008 at 2:24 pm

    This emulsifying business is fascinating. Michael, can you do a post about it sometime? After reading everyone's comments like yours and Bob delGrosso's, I'm ready to start blending all sorts of things to see what they turn into.

    I'm feeling a little "mad scientist" right now.

    Reply
  64. Tags

    May 24, 2008 at 2:25 pm

    Jane Grigson's Charcuterie and French Pork Cookery says it tastes best when made with a bowl and a wooden spoon.

    Don't feel bad, Michael. I've bought four of your Charcuterie books and only one of Jane's.

    Reply
  65. Ms. Glaze

    May 24, 2008 at 4:08 pm

    I've head one reason for mayo breaking is that the egg yolks are too cold. It's better to have yolks that are room temp.

    There are so many great sauces that are mayonnaise based in French cuisine. Try thinning out the mayo with a extra water and adding some chopped cooked chicken livers – a nice cold sauce for chicken breasts. Or add some chopped truffles and extra balsalmic vineger, also equally deelish. Or herbs! Pourquoi pas?

    I make mayo at work with a Kitchenaid and whisk attachment or by hand depending on the quantity needed and how flabby my arms are looking.

    Reply
  66. luis

    May 24, 2008 at 10:23 pm

    Ms. Glaze, I love you!!!!!!!!!! and your blog recipes... but chicken livers?????? pasha!!!!!!! Oh! please come home once in a while..so you can renew yourself!!!!...You are far too french for my simple palate On this one. truffles? please I am trying to buy gasoline. But I whole heartily agree with you that this is a magical technique and a magical sauce that as some here have realized...mainly ME!!!!!!!!!!! is worth fooling around with...THANK YOU MICHAEL!THANK YOU MICHAEL!THANK YOU MICHAEL!THANK YOU MICHAEL! oh, folks go ahead and say it...THANK YOU MICHAEL!

    Reply
  67. Kate

    May 24, 2008 at 11:12 pm

    Hey, and if you're wondering what to do with that extra egg white, a whiskey sour is delicious and provides motivation during all that whisking.

    I just made a batch of this glorious stuff and am resisting the urge to eat it straight out of the bowl. Thanks for the perfect recipe, Ruhlman!

    Reply
  68. cybercita

    May 25, 2008 at 12:02 am

    i just finished reading about mayonnaise in herve´ this' book kitchen mysteries. now i'm doubly inspired!

    Reply
  69. FoodPuta

    May 25, 2008 at 11:01 am

    I've been using my Vita-Mix for making Mayo, and haven't bought Mayo for quite some time now. I'm not sure if this is considered Fo-Paw, but when I don't have a lemon around, I just use white Vinegar.
    One question I do have, is how long is it safe to keep in the Fridge? I only leave it for a couple of days.

    Great Photo's!!

    Reply
  70. Bob delGrosso

    May 25, 2008 at 5:10 pm

    Ms Glaze wrote:

    "I've head one reason for mayo breaking is that the egg yolks are too cold"

    Usually, the egg, oil and watery part (lemon juice, wine, vinegar, whatever) should all be about the same temp and typically, close to room temp. If either one is too cold (or too hot) it will be hard to make a stable emulsion.

    Remember: you are trying to elide two things (oil and water) that are not normally attracted to each other. So you need to minimize the differences as much as possible.

    If one or another ingredient is too hot or too cold there will be problems.

    FoodPuta

    Refrigerated mayonnaise will last for months. Sometimes the handmade stuff looks funky after a couple of days but that does not mean it is bad. Just whisk it a bit and it'll look good as new.

    Reply
  71. Darius K.

    May 26, 2008 at 2:04 pm

    Hi Ruhlman,

    I've made mayonnaise before, but I was inspired by this post to make some fresh mayo for Memorial Day today. This mayo has lime and pepper in it, and will serve the dual purpose of dipping sauce for yucca fries and condiment for burgers. This is also the first time I've made it with a whip instead of a food processor; the texture is definitely superior this way. It's creamy! With a food processor it's more foamy.

    Here's a crappy cell phone pic of the final product. Thanks again for the inspiration.

    Reply
  72. luis

    May 26, 2008 at 4:09 pm

    Getting ready to try a gallatine... making brine, deboning the chicken a la Pepin way.
    Can smell the brine from my office already...yum!!!!!!! The stuffing is a challenge right now. Major Ingredients on hand.. stuffing o'course.. cabagge, onions, carrots, mushrooms and Spinach. Oh and there is spanish chorizo and eggs for additional protein flavor. Kicking the ingredients around... something is bound to click between now and and cooking time. The stuffing is key to making all this work pay off.
    Definitelly plan to keep the gallatine cooking around 3-325 degrees for as long as it takes. For the sauce....I am planning to try something based on this Rhulman technique. I can see the mayonnaise already uses lemon juice a cornerstone of mojo. I am going to try making the mayo with italian spice, Oregano, garlic, pepper, apple cider vinegar and extra virgin olive oil and if I can find them.. chipotle peppers. I will try and whisk it as per master Rhulman's directions.. but if I have to.. I will use the boat motor stick blender on the thing..
    Complicated dishes such as this rarelly work out...This is why I keep a jar of peanut butter within reach at all times. But when they work out and surprise...yummmmmmmmo!!!!!!

    Reply
  73. Brian

    May 26, 2008 at 5:15 pm

    I was afraid of it breaking, so I whisked the hell out of it, and my arm feels like its about to fall off, but damn its good.

    Reply
  74. Mark Boxshus

    May 26, 2008 at 9:18 pm

    I made home made mayonnaise for the first time today, and it was incredible. Making it was very easy, and I'll never (maybe in a pinch) go back to the store bought stuff again. Thanks for the inspiration.

    Mark

    Reply
  75. nmd

    May 27, 2008 at 11:57 am

    I didn't see the answer to whether to try to use half a yolk if making half the recipe. Would you just use a whole one? Thanks!

    Reply
  76. luis

    May 27, 2008 at 3:02 pm

    The galantine is done!... now I am preparing to make the compound mayo sauce using Rhulmans technique. Really needs to be more of a gravy...I'll try a couple of things... worst comes to worst I don't have to use it. This dish is all about incremental assembly.

    Reply
  77. luis

    May 27, 2008 at 3:13 pm

    Nope, the mayo sauce won't go with the mojo chicken. I will have to wait until I do the grilled red snapper later this week or next. This chicken galantine requires a brown sauce not white.

    Reply
  78. Claudia (the Original)

    May 28, 2008 at 1:49 pm

    Oh, Michael, I didn't realize Bourdain hadn't made mayo since the 70's because he'd gotten arthritic - I thought it was the alcohol-induced shaky hands! Thank God Ottavia's the alpha cook in the kitchen these days (!)

    Reply
  79. luis

    May 29, 2008 at 1:10 am

    Well a little off topic but for what is worth. I stopped by the Normans high end specialty market a block up from the Wynn Dixie were I bought the crappy sineue chicken that resulted in probably one of the most sublime dishes I have managed and looked at what a real gourmaid chicken should look like...and wow!!!!!!!!!
    I was discussing with my bro that the amount of work and time I had dedicated to the brinning and the deboning and the making of the stuffing and the roasting of the galantine including making the brown sauce/gravy.... It just doesn't make sense to use a cheap chicken. I know for you guys it's a yawn..but believe me for me, this is a real EUREKA moment in my kitchen. Good ingrediens.. I get it!. Now Bro says that Publix sells a nice organic chicken. I will check it out but the chickens at Norman brothers looked like something right out of Jacques Pepin DVD.

    Reply
  80. Russ H

    June 06, 2008 at 8:57 am

    I made the mayo and it was great! My chef-brother was impressed with it (especially when I told him I hand wisked it). His only criticisms were 1.) to much salt (I thought I put too much in...he confirmed it) and 2.) Too much lemon juice (again, my fault. I didn't measure. I just squeezed a half lemon in, so instead of a teaspoon, I may have had closer to 3+. Oh well)

    And it STILL kicked the crap out of anything that comes in a jar!

    Reply
  81. ingo

    June 09, 2008 at 10:05 pm

    i just took a stab at this, first time making mayo! my first try just never ever got thick at all. it was very disappointing. second try was a charm, i used the whisk attachment on my immersion blender and after a few tense moments and some major oil splattering everything came together beautifully!

    too bad the husband doesn't like mayo. i need to put this on everything i eat. i've been prowling the kitchen for something to dip in it other than my finger.

    Reply
  82. Timothy Ross

    December 02, 2008 at 4:12 pm

    This was one of the funnest/simplest things I have made in a long time. I have always been a mayo enthusiast and was so shocked to see how easy this was. I added garlic, lemon, and a little siracha to mine.

    Reply
  83. sam

    February 26, 2009 at 7:16 pm

    Thanks for the shout out Michael - I guess the truth is that I just can't make mayonnaise. I try and try and try again at all times of the month and only get it right once in a blue moon. I don't know why it eludes me, but it does.I will try again using your instructions. My mayo is always way more yellow, too. Maybe cos I only buy pastured eggs which have glorious yolks.
    I suck. Seriously

    Reply
  84. radish

    February 27, 2009 at 9:44 am

    I wonder where that claim came from re: menstruating women and mayonnaise... Regardless, homemade mayonnaise is ambrosial and breathtaking - once you try it, it's hard to go back to a pre-made one.

    Reply
  85. Marlies

    March 02, 2009 at 2:27 pm

    Messy, Michael's recipe is better than Alton's. Use a food processor though. You never have to worry about the mayo not thickening, or having to do the drop-by-drop oil thing, for that matter. A slow steady stream is fine. The only thing you have to watch though is: have all ingredients at room temp. That's important. You can use an egg yolk or a whole egg. With a whole egg you just have to add more oil. Before adding the oil you can dump all kinds of goodies into the mix, ie fresh garlic, or herbs, or some mustard, or chipotles. The sky's the limit! I make a fresh batch (takes 5 minutes) once a week. There is no Hellman's in my house.

    Reply
  86. Ross

    March 04, 2009 at 2:23 pm

    Good god: mayonaise. I know so many people who say things like, "Chicken salad? Ugh. All that white dressing." It's true: especially in deli foods, the mayo is often alarmingly cheap. "I don't like mayo" is a statement I don't often believe, much like "I don't like bacon." It usually means "I've never had real mayo."

    If only people new. Good post, sir.

    Reply
  87. ML

    August 17, 2009 at 7:43 pm

    Thanks! Your recipe plus photos made me go to the kitchen and make some mayo. It was soo delicious.... And it was exciting precisely because it didn't work. So I kinda hopelessly tried your "rescue" technique and bam! magic! really cool...

    I vaguely remember my mom teaching me how to make mayo, but that was a looong time ago. She actually used a blender.

    My mom is the best cook in the world, but thanks to you humble me can now do something better than she ever did! Can't wait to go visit them...I guess "family competition" is a plate best served creamy...

    Thank you!!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Marlies Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • 12/26 Newsletter (Hope You'll Subscribe!)
  • Newsletter Holiday Cookie Recipes
  • Ga-Ga's Eggnog
  • Friday Cocktail Hour: The Penicillin
  • French Onion Soup

Recent Comments

  • Health Mentor on Newsletter Holiday Cookie Recipes
  • tee on Friday Cocktail Hour: Amaretto Sour
  • Jayce Osinski on 12/26 Newsletter (Hope You'll Subscribe!)
  • slot maxwin on 12/26 Newsletter (Hope You'll Subscribe!)
  • Stephon Kozey on 12/26 Newsletter (Hope You'll Subscribe!)

Copyright © 2026 Ruhlman on the Foodie Pro Theme